Some other substantial reason

Every employer will recognise that sometimes an employee is just not working out.  Often it can be difficult to put your finger on precisely what the problem is and it doesn’t fall squarely under the headings of “conduct”, “performance” or “redundancy”.

A classic example of this is where there is simply a personality clash with an employee.  They could be excellent at their job, but are not able to get on with their manager.

It can be possible, in very select circumstances, to dismiss an employee under the heading “some other substantial reason”.  Tribunals are loathe to allow this practice to become too widespread, so if you think you have an employee to whom this may apply, please make sure you take advice.

Meet the team

Jon Loney
Partner & Head of Employment Team
Employment
Salisbury
023 8082 0468
07515 061 829
Employment
Simon Rhodes
Managing Partner
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0547
07884 184 613
Employment
Holly Cudbill
Associate
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0508
07881 343 957
Employment
Ian Grimshaw
Associate
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0504
07881 343 958
Employment
James Humphery
Senior Solicitor
Employment
Salisbury
01722 426915
Employment
Claire Weal
Paralegal
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0548
Employment
Kelly Lowe
Paralegal
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0529
Employment
Claire Helling
Trainee Solicitor
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0526
Employment
Briony Holland
Trainee Solicitor
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0457
Employment
Rachel Collins
Trainee Chartered Legal Executive
Employment
Southampton
023 8082 0570
Employment
Sayrah Faza
Legal Secretary
Employment
Salisbury
01722 426979
Employment